Hardball History: Who Gets to Speak?
Shared Authority
Shared authority, discussed by Stanton, refers to the collaborative process between historians and the communities they engage with to interpret and present history. Rather than historians being the sole narrators of the past, shared authority invites input from people whose lived experiences, memories, and cultural perspectives shape historical understanding.
Dr. Cathy Stanton
Stanton’s Argument
Stanton’s main argument in Hardball History is that public historians can’t avoid the political nature of their work, especially when engaging with communities and controversial histories. She explains that while some historians try to stay neutral or avoid being labeled as activists, the reality is that public history often involves taking a stand, whether it is intentional or not.
Discussion Questions
How does Stanton suggest historians should approach politically charged historical work?
Stanton argues that historians shouldn’t shy away from politics. Instead, they should acknowledge the political nature of public history and embrace their role as advocates when necessary. Trying to stay “neutral” often reinforces dominant power structures.
How can shared authority change the way we think about museums, monuments, or historical sites?
It can lead to more honest, inclusive, and community-centered interpretations. Rather than presenting a single “official” story, these spaces can become platforms for dialogue, healing, and truth-telling